Accuracy of environmental reconstruction based on a blind test of micromammal evidence from East Africa

Denné Reed, Wendy Dirks, Laura McMaster, Terry Harrison

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Paleoenvironmental reconstructions based on mammalian faunas provide the contextual basis for understanding evolutionary events in many branches of paleobiology. This paper presents the first blind test of an environmental reconstruction using extant African small mammals. We collected 1216 specimens representing a minimum of 332 individuals from Ngofila 3, Tanzania, then conducted a blind analysis of the taxonomic and community composition. We found agreement between the observed habitat and the predicted habitat along eight aspects of the environment: (1) mean annual precipitation, (2) surface water availability, (3) soil type, (4) vegetation, (5) land use, (6) topography, (7) habitat heterogeneity, (8) temperature. Of these, the first six had high agreement between the observed and predicted descriptions, two (topography and habitat heterogeneity) had moderate agreement and the last, (temperature) was discussed in the observed habitat description but not addressed in the predicted description and could not be compared. The high level of agreement demonstrates that paleoenvironmental reconstruction can accurately portray a known habitat. In addition, we suggest factors that should be considered in a standard method of habitat description, which would improve comparability of results between different analyses.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)1-10
    Number of pages10
    JournalHistorical Biology
    DOIs
    StateAccepted/In press - Aug 5 2017

    Fingerprint

    habitats
    Eastern Africa
    Ecosystem
    topography
    temperature
    testing
    Temperature
    small mammals
    Tanzania
    soil types
    surface water
    land use
    fauna
    vegetation
    methodology
    Mammals
    Soil
    Water

    Keywords

    • Africa
    • blind test
    • Micromammals
    • paleoecology
    • paleoenvironment
    • rodents

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Agricultural and Biological Sciences(all)

    Cite this

    Accuracy of environmental reconstruction based on a blind test of micromammal evidence from East Africa. / Reed, Denné; Dirks, Wendy; McMaster, Laura; Harrison, Terry.

    In: Historical Biology, 05.08.2017, p. 1-10.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Reed, Denné; Dirks, Wendy; McMaster, Laura; Harrison, Terry / Accuracy of environmental reconstruction based on a blind test of micromammal evidence from East Africa.

    In: Historical Biology, 05.08.2017, p. 1-10.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    @article{72061d39e53a4da7ac2159a1c0da6112,
    title = "Accuracy of environmental reconstruction based on a blind test of micromammal evidence from East Africa",
    abstract = "Paleoenvironmental reconstructions based on mammalian faunas provide the contextual basis for understanding evolutionary events in many branches of paleobiology. This paper presents the first blind test of an environmental reconstruction using extant African small mammals. We collected 1216 specimens representing a minimum of 332 individuals from Ngofila 3, Tanzania, then conducted a blind analysis of the taxonomic and community composition. We found agreement between the observed habitat and the predicted habitat along eight aspects of the environment: (1) mean annual precipitation, (2) surface water availability, (3) soil type, (4) vegetation, (5) land use, (6) topography, (7) habitat heterogeneity, (8) temperature. Of these, the first six had high agreement between the observed and predicted descriptions, two (topography and habitat heterogeneity) had moderate agreement and the last, (temperature) was discussed in the observed habitat description but not addressed in the predicted description and could not be compared. The high level of agreement demonstrates that paleoenvironmental reconstruction can accurately portray a known habitat. In addition, we suggest factors that should be considered in a standard method of habitat description, which would improve comparability of results between different analyses.",
    keywords = "Africa, blind test, Micromammals, paleoecology, paleoenvironment, rodents",
    author = "Denné Reed and Wendy Dirks and Laura McMaster and Terry Harrison",
    year = "2017",
    month = "8",
    doi = "10.1080/08912963.2017.1360295",
    pages = "1--10",
    journal = "Historical Biology",
    issn = "0891-2963",
    publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Accuracy of environmental reconstruction based on a blind test of micromammal evidence from East Africa

    AU - Reed,Denné

    AU - Dirks,Wendy

    AU - McMaster,Laura

    AU - Harrison,Terry

    PY - 2017/8/5

    Y1 - 2017/8/5

    N2 - Paleoenvironmental reconstructions based on mammalian faunas provide the contextual basis for understanding evolutionary events in many branches of paleobiology. This paper presents the first blind test of an environmental reconstruction using extant African small mammals. We collected 1216 specimens representing a minimum of 332 individuals from Ngofila 3, Tanzania, then conducted a blind analysis of the taxonomic and community composition. We found agreement between the observed habitat and the predicted habitat along eight aspects of the environment: (1) mean annual precipitation, (2) surface water availability, (3) soil type, (4) vegetation, (5) land use, (6) topography, (7) habitat heterogeneity, (8) temperature. Of these, the first six had high agreement between the observed and predicted descriptions, two (topography and habitat heterogeneity) had moderate agreement and the last, (temperature) was discussed in the observed habitat description but not addressed in the predicted description and could not be compared. The high level of agreement demonstrates that paleoenvironmental reconstruction can accurately portray a known habitat. In addition, we suggest factors that should be considered in a standard method of habitat description, which would improve comparability of results between different analyses.

    AB - Paleoenvironmental reconstructions based on mammalian faunas provide the contextual basis for understanding evolutionary events in many branches of paleobiology. This paper presents the first blind test of an environmental reconstruction using extant African small mammals. We collected 1216 specimens representing a minimum of 332 individuals from Ngofila 3, Tanzania, then conducted a blind analysis of the taxonomic and community composition. We found agreement between the observed habitat and the predicted habitat along eight aspects of the environment: (1) mean annual precipitation, (2) surface water availability, (3) soil type, (4) vegetation, (5) land use, (6) topography, (7) habitat heterogeneity, (8) temperature. Of these, the first six had high agreement between the observed and predicted descriptions, two (topography and habitat heterogeneity) had moderate agreement and the last, (temperature) was discussed in the observed habitat description but not addressed in the predicted description and could not be compared. The high level of agreement demonstrates that paleoenvironmental reconstruction can accurately portray a known habitat. In addition, we suggest factors that should be considered in a standard method of habitat description, which would improve comparability of results between different analyses.

    KW - Africa

    KW - blind test

    KW - Micromammals

    KW - paleoecology

    KW - paleoenvironment

    KW - rodents

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85026914860&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85026914860&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1080/08912963.2017.1360295

    DO - 10.1080/08912963.2017.1360295

    M3 - Article

    SP - 1

    EP - 10

    JO - Historical Biology

    T2 - Historical Biology

    JF - Historical Biology

    SN - 0891-2963

    ER -