TY - JOUR
T1 - Further improvement, validation, and application of CymoSkew biotic index for the ecological status assessment of the Greek coastal and transitional waters
AU - Orfanidis, Sotiris
AU - Papathanasiou, Vasillis
AU - Mittas, Nikolaos
AU - Theodosiou, Theodosios
AU - Ramfos, Alexis
AU - Tsioli, Soultana
AU - Kosmidou, Maria
AU - Kafas, Andronikos
AU - Mystikou, Alexandra
AU - Papadimitriou, Apostolos
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2020 Elsevier Ltd
PY - 2020/11
Y1 - 2020/11
N2 - The CymoSkew index, a quantitative expression of Cymodocea's photosynthetic leaf length (PLL) asymmetry, has been used as an early warning response indicator of coastal ecosystem status and trends. Besides its strengths, the number (N) of PLL used and the fact that they are chosen randomly, as well as the difficulty of its application in low-density meadows, were CymoSkew's main weaknesses. A new version of the index (CymoSkewm) was developed using previous and new monitoring studies in eight meadows of the North Aegean Sea. It was also validated on another dataset carried out at six coastal and two transitional meadows and tested against MA-LUSI anthropogenic stress index. To avoid the effect of randomness on the index's accuracy, a random subsampling resampling technique in all PLL values of a meadow has been developed, producing a large number of different subsamples of N=20-300PLL drawn without replacement from all PLL values of a meadow, in order to reconstruct the underlying theoretical distribution of the CymoSkew index and infer about the unknown population mean. The iterated process constitutes the basis for evaluating the empirical distribution of CymoSkew mean values, while the mean value of this new distribution represents the CymoSkewm meadow value, accompanied by empirical confidence intervals. In this way, low-density Cymodocea meadows can be accurately assessed, as PLL's from the whole meadow are utilized and not from one quadrate. Both versions of the index (CymoSkew, CymoSkewm) were significantly linearly correlated together and with the MA-LUSI index (for both analyses p < 0.001). When applying the same procedure to maximum total leaf length (MTLL = PLL + sheath) values per shoot instead of PLL, results were comparable, opening new perspectives of the index's (CymoSkewmMAX) usage, such as its rapid application (1) non-destructively under the seawater, or (2) on carefully cut at the base sheaths to be measured in the field or the lab later on. For routine biomonitoring within the European Union Directives (WFD, 2000/60/EC; Habitat Directive, 92/43/EEC), an open-source web application tool (http://index.cymoskew.gr/) for the computation of Cymoskewm or CymoskewmMAX has been developed.
AB - The CymoSkew index, a quantitative expression of Cymodocea's photosynthetic leaf length (PLL) asymmetry, has been used as an early warning response indicator of coastal ecosystem status and trends. Besides its strengths, the number (N) of PLL used and the fact that they are chosen randomly, as well as the difficulty of its application in low-density meadows, were CymoSkew's main weaknesses. A new version of the index (CymoSkewm) was developed using previous and new monitoring studies in eight meadows of the North Aegean Sea. It was also validated on another dataset carried out at six coastal and two transitional meadows and tested against MA-LUSI anthropogenic stress index. To avoid the effect of randomness on the index's accuracy, a random subsampling resampling technique in all PLL values of a meadow has been developed, producing a large number of different subsamples of N=20-300PLL drawn without replacement from all PLL values of a meadow, in order to reconstruct the underlying theoretical distribution of the CymoSkew index and infer about the unknown population mean. The iterated process constitutes the basis for evaluating the empirical distribution of CymoSkew mean values, while the mean value of this new distribution represents the CymoSkewm meadow value, accompanied by empirical confidence intervals. In this way, low-density Cymodocea meadows can be accurately assessed, as PLL's from the whole meadow are utilized and not from one quadrate. Both versions of the index (CymoSkew, CymoSkewm) were significantly linearly correlated together and with the MA-LUSI index (for both analyses p < 0.001). When applying the same procedure to maximum total leaf length (MTLL = PLL + sheath) values per shoot instead of PLL, results were comparable, opening new perspectives of the index's (CymoSkewmMAX) usage, such as its rapid application (1) non-destructively under the seawater, or (2) on carefully cut at the base sheaths to be measured in the field or the lab later on. For routine biomonitoring within the European Union Directives (WFD, 2000/60/EC; Habitat Directive, 92/43/EEC), an open-source web application tool (http://index.cymoskew.gr/) for the computation of Cymoskewm or CymoskewmMAX has been developed.
KW - Anthropogenic stress
KW - Biotic index
KW - Cymodocea
KW - MA-LUSI
KW - Random subsampling
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85088913776&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85088913776&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.ecolind.2020.106727
DO - 10.1016/j.ecolind.2020.106727
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85088913776
SN - 1470-160X
VL - 118
JO - Ecological Indicators
JF - Ecological Indicators
M1 - 106727
ER -