In vivo evaluation of resorbable supercritical CO₂-treated collagen membranes for class III furcation-guided tissue regeneration

The study evaluated the effects of a Supercritical CO₂ (scCO₂) on a commercially available decellularized/delipidized naturally derived porcine pericardium collagen membrane, Vitala®. The Vitala® and scCO₂ treated experimental membranes were evaluated for guided tissue regeneration (GTR) of periodontal tissue in class III furcation defects utilizing a dog model. Physical material characterization was performed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The in vivo portion of the study was allocated to three-time points (6, 12, and 24-weeks) using standardized class III furcation defects created in the upper second and third premolars. The experimental defects (n = 5) were covered with either a collagen membrane (positive control), scCO₂-treated collagen membrane (experimental) or no membrane (negative control). Following sacrifice, histologic serial sections were performed from cervical to apical for morphologic/morphometric evaluation. Morphometric evaluation was carried out by ranking the presence of collagen membrane, amount of bone formation within the defect site and inflammatory cell infiltrate content. SEM showed the experimental scCO₂-treated membrane to have a similar gross fibrous appearance and chemical structure in comparison to the Vitala® Collagen membrane. A significant increase in membrane thickness was noted in the scCO₂-treated membranes (366 ± 54 μm) vs non-treated membranes (265 ± 75 μm). TGA and DSC spectra indicated no significant qualitative differences between the two membranes. For the in vivo results, both membranes indicated significantly greater amounts of newly formed bone (scCO₂: 2.85 ± 1.1; Vitala®: 2.80 ± 1.0) within the covered defects relative to uncovered controls (0.8 ± 0.27) at 24 weeks. Both membrane types gradually degraded as time elapsed in vivo from 6 to 12 weeks, and presented nearly complete resorption at 24 weeks. The inflammatory infiltrate at regions in proximity with the membranes was commensurate with healthy tissue levels from 6 weeks in vivo on, and periodontal ligament regeneration onset was detected at 12 weeks in vivo. The effect of the supplementary scCO₂ treatment step on the collagen membrane was demonstrated to be biocompatible, allowing for the infiltration of cells and degradation over time. The treated membranes presented similar performance in GTR to non-treated samples in Class III furcation lesions. Defects treated without membranes failed to achieve regeneration of the native periodontium.