Unreflective Partisans? Policy Information and Evaluation in the Development of Partisanship

Ted Brader, Joshua A. Tucker

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    What factors enable and motivate citizens to form partisan identities? Popular accounts, as well as several major theoretical approaches, attribute a central role for policy and ideological concerns in shaping the partisan orientations of voters. Information about the policy aims of parties should therefore, on average, make it easier for an individual to find a party that best fits her views, especially if she had previously been less familiar with the parties. The evidence for this is mixed, however. Plenty of studies find a robust correlation between policy views and partisanship. Yet there is mounting evidence that citizens look to parties to decide where to stand on policy issues, suggesting that partisan identification precedes policy preferences. We bring new evidence to bear by investigating directly the impact of substantive policy information on the partisan identities of ordinary citizens. To do this, we carry out a pair of original experiments across six countries, five of which are relatively young or unstable party systems. One experiment informs citizens about the policy goals of the major parties; we find little to no evidence that such information affects levels of partisanship. The other experiment tests the impact of inviting citizens to evaluate and compare their own position to the positions of the major parties, a more direct test of the sort of reasoning posited in some theoretical accounts. We find that this reflective task in fact depresses levels of partisanship, perhaps especially among those who knew less about politics and parties from the outset. This suggests that thinking about policy differences and proximities pushes citizens away from partisan attachments they form in the ordinary course of life, perhaps because such thinking generates fresh doubts or focuses attention on facets of partisan choice that matter less in typical processes of preference formation.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)137-157
    Number of pages21
    JournalPolitical Psychology
    Volume39
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Feb 1 2018

    Keywords

    • Bulgaria
    • Great Britain
    • Hungary
    • Moldova
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • experimental analysis
    • experiments
    • partisanship
    • party identification

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Social Psychology
    • Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
    • Clinical Psychology
    • Philosophy
    • Sociology and Political Science
    • Political Science and International Relations

    Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Unreflective Partisans? Policy Information and Evaluation in the Development of Partisanship'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

  • Cite this